Alberta · ACO (optometrists) & COA (opticians)
What happens during an ACO investigation?
Whether your regulator is the Alberta College of Optometrists or the College of Opticians of Alberta, an investigation under the Health Professions Act has the same built-in endpoint: once it is complete, the matter is referred to the Hearing Tribunal unless it is dismissed as trivial, vexatious, or without merit. That makes the investigation stage the point where a strong response can keep your matter from ever reaching a hearing.
How an investigation starts
The Complaints Director refers a matter for investigation when informal resolution is not appropriate or when more information is needed. An investigation is mandatory for serious allegations of unprofessional conduct, so a formal investigation is not, in itself, a sign that the college has judged you.
The investigator’s powers
An investigator appointed under the Health Professions Act can compel you to produce records and documents, and interview you and other witnesses. In eye care, the records at the centre of a matter are often your examination findings, prescriptions, and dispensing records, and Alberta’s Health Information Act governs how that information is handled throughout.
The process can be intrusive and disruptive to your practice. Resisting it is not a workable strategy; meeting it fully, with advice, is — and it is often what allows a matter to be resolved without a hearing.
Your duty to cooperate
You are expected to cooperate with the investigation. Obstructing it, or giving evasive answers, is itself a concern and can be treated as seriously as the matter under investigation. Honesty is central: do not reconstruct or embellish an account, and if something went wrong, say so plainly. You are entitled to be represented, and you should be.
Records and disclosure
You can be compelled to produce records, so keep them to your college’s standards, keep your own copies, and never alter them after the fact. Contemporaneous notes — made at the time of care or dispensing — carry far more weight than anything written once a complaint has arrived, which is why good day-to-day documentation is your strongest protection long before any investigation.
What the endpoint is
This is the point that is easiest to miss. When the investigation concludes, the matter is referred to the Hearing Tribunal unless it is dismissed as trivial, vexatious, or without merit. That makes your conduct during the investigation, and the quality of your response, decisive: it shapes whether the matter is dismissed, resolved by agreement, or sent to a hearing.
Interim measures during the investigation
Where a matter is serious enough that patients may be at risk, the college can impose interim conditions on your practice permit, or suspend it, while the investigation continues. Interim measures affecting your practice can be reflected on the public record.
The Hearing Tribunal, and what follows
The Hearing Tribunal determines the facts, whether the conduct amounts to unprofessional conduct, and any sanction — from a caution or reprimand to conditions on your practice permit, a remedial course of study, a fine, costs, suspension, or cancellation of your registration. Hearings are generally open and decisions are published, and the Act sets mandatory minimum sanctions for findings of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct. A decision can be appealed to the college’s Council, and from Council to the Court of Appeal of Alberta. Where there is a reasonable belief that a criminal offence has occurred, the tribunal must forward its decision to the Minister of Justice.
Key takeaways
- Under the Health Professions Act, a completed investigation is referred to the Hearing Tribunal unless it is dismissed as trivial, vexatious, or without merit.
- Investigators can compel your records and documents and interview you; the process can be intrusive.
- Cooperate honestly and never alter records — involve your insurer’s legal support or a lawyer early.
- Keep records to your college’s standards; contemporaneous notes carry the weight.
- The college can impose interim conditions on, or suspend, your practice permit during the investigation.
- Hearing Tribunal decisions are public and can be appealed to Council and then the Court of Appeal of Alberta.
Related courses
Continue reading
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the Complaints Director and the Hearing Tribunal?
The Complaints Director handles intake and can resolve, investigate, or dismiss a matter. The Hearing Tribunal holds the discipline hearing and decides whether conduct is unprofessional and what sanction applies.
Can the college compel my records?
Yes. An investigator appointed under the Health Professions Act can compel you to produce records and documents and can interview you.
What happens when the investigation finishes?
Unless the matter is dismissed as trivial, vexatious, or without merit, it is referred to the Hearing Tribunal.
Do I have to cooperate with the investigator?
Yes. Cooperation is expected, and obstruction can itself be a concern. Take advice on how to respond and be represented.
Can I keep practising during the investigation?
Usually yes, unless the college imposes interim conditions on your practice permit or suspends it.
Can I appeal a Hearing Tribunal decision?
Yes. You can appeal to the college’s Council, and from Council to the Court of Appeal of Alberta.
This guide explains how the Alberta College of Optometrists (ACO) and the College of Opticians of Alberta (COA) handle investigation about optometrists and opticians under the Health Professions Act. It is general information, not legal advice. For advice on your own situation, contact your professional liability insurer — which for many optometrists and opticians is arranged through a national association program and usually includes support for a college complaint — or a lawyer experienced in health-profession regulation in Alberta. Last updated July 15, 2026.